New: OddsHype is now on Google PlayGet the Android app →App Store: coming soon
OddsHypePricingStart free
☰

Betting Underdogs vs Favorites: What the Math Actually Says

Is it better to bet underdogs or favorites? How implied probability, vig, the favorite–longshot bias and variance affect each, and why price matters more than side.

By the OddsHype team · · 3 min read
In this guide
  1. Break-even rates
  2. Favorite–longshot bias
  3. Public favorites
  4. Variance differences
  5. Price beats side
  6. Frequently asked questions

Neither underdogs nor favorites are automatically better bets. What matters is whether the price is better than the true probability. That said, two patterns are useful: sportsbooks often load more margin onto longshots (the favorite–longshot bias), and recreational bettors tend to overbet popular favorites. The result: some underdogs and some favorites are +EV, and the only way to know is to compare prices with fair odds.

Break-even rates

OddsWin rate needed
−30075.0%
−20066.7%
−15060.0%
−11052.4%
+15040.0%
+20033.3%
+40020.0%

Use the break-even calculator. (Break-even win percentage by odds.)

Favorite–longshot bias

In many markets, longshots are overpriced relative to their true chances — books and bettors overvalue the dream of a big payout. Props, futures and big underdogs often carry the most margin. (Futures betting value.)

Public favorites

Popular teams and heavy favorites can get bet up by recreational money, especially in parlays. Sometimes that makes the underdog side slightly better value — but this is a general tendency, not a rule. (Public betting percentages.)

Variance differences

  • Favorites: win more often, smaller payouts, smoother results — but one loss erases several wins.
  • Underdogs: win less often, bigger payouts, longer losing streaks.

Size bets accordingly. (Kelly criterion, variance and sample size.)

Price beats side

Example: true probability of Team A winning is 62%.

  • At −150 (60% implied), Team A is +EV.
  • At −180 (64.3% implied), Team A is −EV, and the underdog side may be +EV at the right price.

Same team, different price, opposite conclusion. That's why line shopping and +EV betting focus on price, not picks.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to bet favorites or underdogs?

Neither is inherently better. Bet whichever side is priced better than its true probability.

Do underdogs win more money long term?

Not automatically. Some underdog markets carry more margin due to the favorite–longshot bias.

Why do favorites seem to win so often but bettors still lose?

Heavy favorites require high win rates to break even, and vig reduces returns.

What is the favorite–longshot bias?

The tendency for longshots to be overpriced (paying less than their true odds suggest) compared with favorites.

Put this to work automatically
OddsHype compares every legal sportsbook in your state, finds +EV bets, arbitrage and props, and tracks every bet you place. Free account, no card. 21+.
Start free

Educational content, not betting advice. No strategy guarantees a profit; past results do not predict future results. Bet only where it is legal for you and only what you can afford to lose. Gambling problem? Call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.